Most homes in Siesta Key
Homes each company reports in Siesta Key56homes in Siesta Key
The largest vacation rental manager in Siesta Key is Siesta 4 Rent, with 56 homes.
Comparent lists 23 vacation rental management companies serving Siesta Key, Florida, and 8 are verified. The largest by homes managed in Siesta Key is Siesta 4 Rent (56). A typical company here manages 59 homes in total.
Updated Sources: company-reported portfolios, Airbnb, Vrbo and Google ratings, Comparent owner reviewsHow we rank
Showing 1–20 of 23 managers
Only the 1 company that reports homes in Siesta Key qualifies. Ratings are each company's overall rating on that site; ties go to the company with more reviews. Sponsored placement never changes these lists.
56homes in Siesta Key
The largest vacation rental manager in Siesta Key is Siesta 4 Rent, with 56 homes.
Founded In 1997
Manages 57 properties, 56 in Siesta Key, Florida
Still Local. Still Here. Still Siesta. Siesta 4 Rent is a locally owned and operated vacation rental and property management company serving Siesta Key since 1997. With over 25 years of experience, we offer unmatched local expertise…View full profile of Siesta 4 Rent (opens in a new tab)
StayTerra is a collection of premier vacation rental brands committed to providing best-in-class property management for owners and seamless, elevated experiences for guests in top destinations across America. Our long-term vision is…View full profile of StayTerra (opens in a new tab)
Founded In 2008
Manages 123 properties
Welcome to The Cottages on the Key, an exclusive vacation rental management company with a boutique collection of luxury vacation homes located in Siesta Key, Lido Key, Anna Maria Island and the mainland of Sarasota, Florida. We offer…View full profile of The Cottages On The Key, Inc. (opens in a new tab)
Manages 25 properties
At The Compass Collection, we have a passion for luxury vacation rental marketing and management, and we are experts at providing a concierge level of personal service. Years of experience, and our proven and successful art of…View full profile of The Compass Collection (opens in a new tab)
Founded In 1993
Lifecycle management specialists: Buy/Sell, Manage and Maintain. Best returns for investors at the same time offering the best experience for tenant both short and long term. Purchasing a property for personal or investment reasons in…View full profile of Sterling Realty (opens in a new tab)
Founded In 2019
At Siesta Key Property Management LLC, we understand that owner management is a crucial aspect of rental property management. Our team of experts is dedicated to providing our clients with the best owner management services to ensure…View full profile of Siesta Key Property Management LLC (opens in a new tab)
Founded In 2017
Manages 130 properties
iTrip Sarasota & Venice: Local Experts, National Reach iTrip Sarasota & Venice is a full-service management firm dedicated to maximizing revenue and providing world-class care for Suncoast homeowners. Locally owned and operated, we…View full profile of iTrip Sarasota & Venice (opens in a new tab)
Founded In 2022
SkyRun Sarasota Vacation Rentals is a franchise. We are locally owned and operated delivering superior service to homeowners and guests while actively engaging in the communities in which we operate. Because we operate a small number…View full profile of SkyRun Sarasota (opens in a new tab)
Manages 133 properties
Manages 63 properties
Manages 14 properties
Manages 7 properties
Manages 46 properties
Manages 59 properties
Manages 4 properties
Companies on Comparent report an average of $518 a night at 46.7% occupancy on Airbnb (337 homes) and $406 a night at 43.5% on Vrbo (347 homes).
| Siesta Key | Airbnb | Vrbo |
|---|---|---|
| Homes listed by companies on Comparent | 337 | 347 |
| Average nightly rate | $518 | $406 |
| Average occupancy | 46.7% | 43.5% |
| Houses / condos | 41% / 32% | 57% / 20% |
| Most common size | 2 bedrooms (44%) | 2 bedrooms (32%) |
| Average company rating | 4.77 | 4.55 |
Comparent lists 23 companies serving Siesta Key; 8 are verified (November 2026).
Siesta 4 Rent manages 56 homes in Siesta Key.
Homes run by companies on Comparent average $518 a night at 46.7% occupancy on Airbnb, and $406 a night at 43.5% on Vrbo.