Comparent
The Cottages On The Key, Inc. logo

The Cottages On The Key, Inc.

Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent
Headquarters
Siesta Key, Florida, 34242-2664
Founded in
2008
Full-time employees
19
Markets served
5
  • Owner4.9Owner: 7 reviews
  • 4.8Airbnb: 194 reviews
  • 4.8Vrbo: 1,466 reviews
  • 4.9Google: 322 reviews

Who is The Cottages On The Key, Inc.?

The Cottages On The Key, Inc. is a vacation rental management company based in Siesta Key, Florida, founded in 2008. It has 19 full-time employees and operates in the Anna Maria Island market. It has a 4.9 rating on Owner from 7 reviews, a 4.8 rating on Airbnb from 194 reviews, a 4.8 rating on Vrbo from 1466 reviews, and a 4.9 rating on Google from 322 reviews.

Source: summary written by Comparent from the facts on this page; description written by the company.

In The Cottages On The Key, Inc.’s own words

Written by The Cottages On The Key, Inc.

Welcome to The Cottages on the Key, an exclusive vacation rental management company with a boutique collection of luxury vacation homes located in Siesta Key, Lido Key, Anna Maria Island and the mainland of Sarasota, Florida. We offer complete vacation rental management and asset preservation services for owners/investors and our guest services are offered 24/7.

Where does The Cottages On The Key, Inc. manage vacation rentals?

The Cottages On The Key, Inc. serves one market on Comparent: Anna Maria Island, FL. Its headquarters is in Siesta Key, FL.

Source: places and property counts reported by the company.

How do homeowners rate The Cottages On The Key, Inc.?

4.9 out of 5 from 7 homeowner reviews on Comparent; 4.8 on Airbnb (194); 4.8 on Vrbo (1466); 4.9 on Google (322).

  • Owner4.9Owner: 7 reviews
  • 4.8Airbnb: 194 reviews
  • 4.8Vrbo: 1,466 reviews
  • 4.9Google: 322 reviews

Source: homeowner reviews collected on Comparent; other ratings collected by Comparent from those sites. As of: latest homeowner review August 5, 2025; Airbnb, Vrbo, and Google ratings collected Nov 2026.

4.9

Owner’s rating from 7 reviews

Cleanliness
5.0 out of 5, from 7 reviews
Financial
4.7 out of 5, from 7 reviews
Maintenance
5.0 out of 5, from 7 reviews
Responsiveness
5.0 out of 5, from 7 reviews
Service
5.0 out of 5, from 7 reviews

Your trust is our highest priority. Our reviews are genuine and unbiased — companies cannot pay to modify or remove them.

7 reviews

  • Nique H.

    August 5, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    Cottages on the Key has been reliable and communicative.  They have done a great job keeping both of our rental homes booked, and also have been great partners in keeping them well maintained so they feel like home when we visit!

  • Amy

    May 5, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    The Cottages on the Key are exceptional! We've had the pleasure of working with them since 2015 when we started with Heather. She is amazing and energetic! Since then, the whole team has exceeded our expectations. They are full service which makes it very easy for the owner. Matt helped us find a property to purchase and a contractor to update it beautifully. This was key! Also, they are very proactive and use the latest technology to maximize revenue and to elevate the guest and owner experience. Their transparency and financial reporting are top notch and very informative! We also rely on Greer often for various things. She is very knowledgeable, resourceful and prompt! More recently, Austin was assigned to be our Owner Experience Coordinator...he coordinates projects that we want to get done on our house which helps keep it stress-free for us. Maintenance issues are handled quickly and their maintenance team finds creative, cost-effective solutions. Overall, we appreciate our property management team for their professionalism, friendliness, clear communication and commitment to keeping the property well-maintained and immaculately cleaned. Highly recommend!

  • Tom

    May 5, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    The Cottages on The Key is the most comprehensive property manager. They hit on all facets.

  • David S.

    May 1, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    I have been with the Cottages on the key for 5 years. Before joining, we took about a year and looked and spoke to every management company that had a solid reputation. The Cottages, at that time, were not covering my location. Not one of those companies gave my wife and I confidence that they could take care of our house and give those a guests a real first class experience. We were about to shut down the concept of renting. But then, Matt and Heather, came back and said they were now considering expanding into my area. We met and and they solidly convinced us that they were the right company for us. We have never regretted that choice and they continue to live up to the promises they made in that first meeting. Our occupancy rates are high, but most importantly, with the right guests. People who have been screened and vetted to respect the house and the neighbors around us. They are super responsive and for the last five years they have proven the ability to satisfy my owner requirements and the requirements of discerning guests. They are simply the BEST!!

  • Mary O.

    May 1, 2025

    4.6out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    3.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    Excellent service, cleanliness and maintenance. Makes living remotely easy. Ongoing periodic communication with owners on any feedback from renters, maintenance issues is only recommendation.

Can I trust The Cottages On The Key, Inc.?

Comparent verified The Cottages On The Key, Inc.'s identity. It lists 3 memberships, including Airbnb Superhost and Vrbo Premier Partner.

Verified by Comparent
Comparent confirmed this company's identity and that the person managing the profile works there.
Granted by Comparent
Airbnb Superhost
Declared by the company
Vrbo Premier Partner
Declared by the company
VRNation
Declared by the company

Source: verification and awards by Comparent; memberships as declared by The Cottages On The Key, Inc.. Meanings written by Comparent.

What does The Cottages On The Key, Inc. do for owners?

The Cottages On The Key, Inc. says 13 services in all.

  • Trust Accounting
  • Property Inspections
  • Revenue Management/Dynamic Pricing
  • Local Ownership
  • Guest Screening/ID Verification
  • Guest Damage Insurance/Security Deposit Insurance Program
  • Local Support 24/7
  • Tax Compliance and Remittance
  • Commercial Laundry
  • In-house Cleaning
  • Keyless Entry Provided
  • SmartHome
  • Unlimited Owner Use

Source: services the company says it offers. Definitions written by Comparent, the same on every profile.

How big is The Cottages On The Key, Inc.'s business?

The Cottages On The Key, Inc.'s size, as reported by the company, with a team of 19 full-time employees.

Reported by the property manager, not independently verified.

Active properties
123
Average annual daily rate
$617
Average annual occupancy
73%

Property types

Property types
  • Homes89%
  • Condos11%

Bedroom mix

Bedroom mix
  • 1 bed8%
  • 2 bed8%
  • 3 bed38%
  • 4 bed26%
  • 5 bed4%
  • 6+ bed16%
Active properties
65
Average daily rate
$1,275
Occupancy
18%
Reviews per property
1.0

Property types

Property types
  • Homes97%
  • Condos3%

Bedroom mix

Bedroom mix
  • 1 bed5%
  • 2 bed15%
  • 3 bed30%
  • 4 bed29%
  • 5 bed6%
  • 6+ bed15%
Active properties
109
Average daily rate
$846
Occupancy
45%
Reviews per property
13.3

Property types

Property types
  • Homes100%

Bedroom mix

Bedroom mix
  • 1 bed7%
  • 2 bed9%
  • 3 bed36%
  • 4 bed31%
  • 5 bed3%
  • 6+ bed14%

The metrics and data displayed above are sourced from publicly available information. While Comparent strives to ensure that this information is reliable, please note that the data is not guaranteed for accuracy and should be independently verified. We disclaim any liability for any inaccuracies or omissions in these metrics.

Source: figures reported by The Cottages On The Key, Inc.; review counts collected by Comparent from Airbnb, Vrbo and Google.

Questions The Cottages On The Key, Inc. hasn't answered yet

The Cottages On The Key, Inc. hasn’t claimed this listing yet, so it hasn’t given Comparent these answers. You can ask in your message, or compare other managers who have.

Who will I work with at The Cottages On The Key, Inc.?
No named contact listed.

How do I contact The Cottages On The Key, Inc.?

Send a message with the form below. The Cottages On The Key, Inc. will see your name, email and message and reply to you directly.

Go to the message form

More questions about The Cottages On The Key, Inc.

The Cottages On The Key, Inc.’s own answers, all open.

1. Commission & Costs: Please explain your commission structure and any additional costs a homeowner might incur.

Our base commission structure is 25% of the rental revenue. This is 5% more than most of the other companies on the barrier islands. That said, our company has grown year over year in property count and owner revenue. Part of this success is the additional costs we pay on the owner's behalf, such as:

  • Photography and matterport tours
  • Videography
  • City, county, and state licensing and registration
  • VRBO and other OTA marketing costs
  • Most competitive handyman costs ($45/hr versus $60+/hr with others)
  • Dedicated owner experience coordinator hired to save owners time and money

2. Marketing: Please detail the strategies you utilize to market properties to guests.

With a dedicated marketing team to spear head exposure and distribution, our team is constantly exploring new listing channels, optimizing SEO, google ad spend, and leveraging Social Media to increase exposure of our homeowner's property.

We boast over a 35% return guest rate and a 47% direct booking rate.

3. Cleaning & Maintenance: Please outline your property management services, including but not limited to cleaning, inspections and maintenance.

We handle all aspects of the operations for your investment home. We have brand standard trained cleaners, maintenance workers who are are skilled in various levels of home care, and deep bench of trusted vendors who care for your asset.

5. Financial Management: Please discuss how you handle financial management for the properties you manage. Do you follow trust accounting principles?

Our company operates in trust accounting practices. This includes payment on departure. owners are paid monthly by the 15th of the month following the guest departure.

6. Technology: What kind of technology do you employ and how does this technology provide benefits to both homeowners and guests?

We have live sales agent 18 hrs a day for on call booking inquiries.

Homeowners can choose to use our technology to be the point of contact of guests trhoug automations and tech services or they can opt in to 24/7 in-house guest communication services.

7. Differentiators: What unique aspects set your company apart from other property management companies, especially in terms of advantages to homeowners?

Our company focuses solely on the vacation rental management of your home. We do not sell real estate, own our own portfolio of homes, or focus on long term rentals. This proves to be a strong advantage compared to others who are more focused on areas outside of vacation rental management.

8. Guest Damage: What is your approach to managing damages caused by guests? Do you require a security deposit or offer damage insurance? If you opt for insurance, how do you establish the coverage details?

Guest damage insurance is a mandatory fee that the guest pays. This covers $3000 of guest incidentals per reservation. If there was damages beyond that (which has not happened yet), the guest would have their credit card on file charged.

9. Revenue Management: Please explain your strategy for revenue management? How do you determine pricing to optimize earnings? Do you utilize dynamic pricing software, manage rates manually, or employ a combination of both methods?

We employ 4 full staff members in our revenue management and data analytics department. We have dynamic pricing software that is implemented, maintained, and adjusted by our team. This includes daily booking review audits, pacing reports, and RevPar optimization.

10. Community Involvement and Reputation: Are you involved in the local community and do you support local initiatives?

Our current community endeavor is supporting 40 Carrots, a non profit designed to help single mothers, foster care children, and at risk adolescents.

Source: answers written by The Cottages On The Key, Inc..