Comparent

Vacation rental management companies in Key West, FL

Comparent lists 32 vacation rental management companies serving Key West, Florida, and 5 are verified. The largest by homes managed in Key West is AvantStay (64). A typical company here manages 68 homes in total.

Updated Sources: company-reported portfolios, Airbnb, Vrbo and Google ratings, Comparent owner reviewsHow we rank

Filters

Homeowner reviews
Airbnb rating
Vrbo rating
Google rating

All 32 companies serving Key West

Showing 1–20 of 32 managers

Market overview: the best vacation rental managers in Key West

Only the 1 company that reports homes in Key West qualifies. Ratings are each company's overall rating on that site; ties go to the company with more reviews. Sponsored placement never changes these lists.

Most homes in Key West

Homes each company reports in Key West

64homes in Key West

The largest vacation rental manager in Key West is AvantStay, with 64 homes.

Best Airbnb rating

500+ Airbnb reviews

4.70from 65,202 reviews

The best-rated vacation rental manager on Airbnb in Key West is AvantStay, at 4.70 from 65,202 reviews.

Best Vrbo rating

500+ Vrbo reviews

4.8from 23,328 reviews

The best-rated vacation rental manager on Vrbo in Key West is AvantStay, at 4.8 from 23,328 reviews.

Best homeowner rating

3+ owner reviews on Comparent

Rated by homeowners on Comparent, the best vacation rental manager in Key West is AvantStay, at 4.9 from 9 reviews.

Best Google rating

100+ Google reviews

4.6from 2,375 reviews

The best-rated vacation rental manager on Google in Key West is AvantStay, at 4.6 from 2,375 reviews.

  1. SponsoredVerified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent

    Founded In 2017

    Manages 3,103 properties, 64 in Key West, Florida

    Headquarters
    Los Angeles, CA
    Also in
    Key West, FL
    Employees
    275
    • Homeowner reviews rating 4.9 out of 5 from 9 reviews
    • Airbnb rating 4.7 out of 5 from 65,202 reviews
    • Vrbo rating 4.8 out of 5 from 23,328 reviews
    • Google rating 4.6 out of 5 from 2,375 reviews

    AvantStay is the best way to travel for groups, offering a diverse portfolio of 2,500+ premier vacation rental properties across 140 destinations. As the next generation hospitality platform redefining the way in which people travel…View full profile of AvantStay (opens in a new tab)

    • 2026 Comparent 100
    • Actual Winter 2026 Badge
    • The Comparent 100 Page
  2. Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent

    Founded In 2008

    Manages 4,005 properties

    Headquarters
    Knoxville, TN
    Also in
    Key West, FL
    • No Homeowner reviews rating yet
    • Airbnb rating 4.8 out of 5 from 16,024 reviews
    • Vrbo rating 4.8 out of 5 from 23,129 reviews
    • Google rating 4.7 out of 5 from 2,233 reviews

    iTrip® was created in 2008 when founders Steve Presley, Todd Morrison and Tom Bissmeyer - each an owner of short-term rental properties - realized both property owners and guests needed a higher level of service than what was…View full profile of iTrip Corporate (opens in a new tab)

    • 2026 Comparent 100
    • The Comparent 100 Page
  3. Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent

    Manages 2,622 properties

    Headquarters
    Portland, OR
    Also in
    Key West, FL
    • No Homeowner reviews rating yet
    • Airbnb rating 4.9 out of 5 from 5,468 reviews
    • Vrbo rating 4.8 out of 5 from 46 reviews
    • Google rating 4.0 out of 5 from 20 reviews

    Fairly puts the care back in vacation rental management, delivering the individualized attention you and your property deserve. Fairly’s Caretaker Model With Fairly, you choose a dedicated caretaker who handles the day-to-day…View full profile of Fairly (opens in a new tab)

    • 2026 Comparent 100
    • The Comparent 100 Page
  4. Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent
    Headquarters
    Key West, FL
    • No Homeowner reviews rating yet

    iTrip Key West manages vacation rentals along 20 islands in the lower Florida Keys from Key West to Layton. Our Key West vacation rentals offer a tropical retreat in one of Florida's most beautiful destinations. It’s all about island…View full profile of iTrip Key West (opens in a new tab)

Key West vacation rental market in numbers

Companies on Comparent report an average of $579 a night at 49.1% occupancy on Airbnb (2,134 homes) and $665 a night at 41.9% on Vrbo (1,781 homes).

Totalled across the Airbnb and Vrbo listings of the companies on Comparent in Key West. Homeowner rating average 4.90; Google 4.52. How we rank
Key WestAirbnbVrbo
Homes listed by companies on Comparent2,1341,781
Average nightly rate$579$665
Average occupancy49.1%41.9%
Houses / condos78% / 10%76% / 13%
Most common size2 bedrooms (23%)2 bedrooms (27%)
Average company rating4.784.72

Questions about vacation rental managers in Key West

How many vacation rental management companies are there in Key West, FL?

Comparent lists 32 companies serving Key West; 5 are verified (November 2026).

Which is the largest vacation rental manager in Key West?

AvantStay manages 64 homes in Key West.

Which Key West managers have the best guest ratings?

On Airbnb (500+ reviews): AvantStay (4.70 from 65,202 reviews). Rated by homeowners on Comparent: AvantStay (4.9 from 9 reviews).

How much do vacation rentals earn in Key West?

Homes run by companies on Comparent average $579 a night at 49.1% occupancy on Airbnb, and $665 a night at 41.9% on Vrbo.