Comparent
You're viewing the Spring 2025 edition. See the current edition.

Vacation Rental Management

Market Leaders — Spring 2025

47Total Companies
$1.3BAnnual Revenue
18,094Properties Managed
Market Leader Spring 2025
4.75Avg. Guest Review
396,782Total Reviews
Loading map…
Nightly Rental ManagementSpringfield, MO
19Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 5.0 out of 5100.00
Curate TellurideTelluride
27Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.9 out of 599.47
Vacation Rental CoSteamboat Springs, CO
18Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.9 out of 599.37
Myrtle Beach DestinationsMyrtle Beach, SC
188Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.9 out of 598.87
Moving MountainsSteamboat Springs, CO
249Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.9 out of 598.50
Bluewater Vacation HomesSan Diego, CA
103Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 598.40
Tahoe Signature PropertiesTruckee, CA
45Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 598.40
Book Our PlaceSebastopol, CA
11Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 598.37
MINNeSTAYMinneapolis, MN
93Owner rating 4.9 out of 5Guest rating 4.9 out of 598.33
Luxury Rentals of Hilton HeadHilton Head Island, SC
26Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 598.27
Happy Palm StaysCocoa Beach, FL
400Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 598.08
Juniper Holiday + HomeUnion Pier, MI
51Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 598.01
host2coastHilton Head Island, SC
227Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 597.97
Suches Vacation RentalsSuches, GA
84Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 597.97
Book NOLANew Orleans, LA
85Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 597.93
Koloa Kai Vacation RentalsKalaheo, HI
74Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 597.89
Red Rock Vacation RentalsSt George, UT
490Owner rating 4.9 out of 5Guest rating 4.9 out of 597.87
Stay Bubo Vacation RentalsWashington, DC
134Owner rating 4.9 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 597.45
Mountain Laurel Chalets, Inc.Gatlinburg, TN
95Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 597.37
Stay MontanaBig Sky, MT
372Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 597.33
Stay Montana GallatinBig Sky, MT
365Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 597.30
Coastal Carolina Vacations and SalesNags Head, NC
145Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 597.28
STR ManagementAustin, TX
214Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 597.24
Current Tides Vacation RentalsOrange Beach, AL
80Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 597.03
Element Vacation HomesKissimmee
32Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 597.00
Seaside Vacations & SalesChincoteague, VA
565Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 596.93
Joseph Ellen Properties, LLCJacksonville, FL
169Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 596.87
Saltwater GrandeMyrtle Beach, SC
60Owner rating 4.9 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 596.74
Beachside Vacation RentalsCocoa Beach, FL
315Owner rating 4.9 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 596.73
Southern Comfort Cabin RentalsBlue Ridge, GA
223Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 596.71
Winter Park EscapesTabernash, CO
225Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 596.65
CasagoPortland, OR
130Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 596.58
AvantStayLos Angeles, CA
3,103Owner rating 4.9 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 596.33
Stay TexasFredericksburg, TX
213Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.6 out of 596.33
Roelens VacationsCape Coral, FL
443Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.6 out of 596.33
Blue Ridge Mountain RentalsBoone
720Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.6 out of 596.00
Beachball PropertiesOrange Beach, AL
334Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.6 out of 595.94
Memories Vacation Home ManagementKissimmee, FL
125Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.6 out of 595.72
ArrivedBend, OR
322Owner rating 4.9 out of 5Guest rating 4.7 out of 595.52
Scenic StaysDestin, FL
455Owner rating 4.9 out of 5Guest rating 4.6 out of 595.50
Liquid Life Vacation RentalsOrange Beach, AL
816Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.6 out of 595.44
Beach GetawaysOrange Beach, AL
609Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.6 out of 595.36
Sea Mountain VacationsNorth Myrtle Beach, SC
58Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.5 out of 595.13
Family Time Vacation RentalsBryce Canyon City, UT
179Owner rating 5.0 out of 5Guest rating 4.5 out of 595.00
Lewis Realty Associates, Inc.Surf City, NC
155Owner rating 4.9 out of 5Guest rating 4.5 out of 594.16
Casiola Vacation HomesOrlando, FL
395Owner rating 4.8 out of 5Guest rating 4.5 out of 593.20
Mountain Time Vacation RentalsFort Collins, CO
218Owner rating 4.5 out of 5Guest rating 4.8 out of 592.63

Last updated:

How Market Leaders Are Chosen

Building a Strong Foundation (Pass/Fail)

  • Complete Profile: A comprehensive profile showcases the company's expertise and fosters trust with homeowners. This includes a detailed description, insightful FAQs, and a clear outline of services offered.
  • Multi-Platform Guest Reviews: We gather reviews from multiple trusted platforms like Airbnb, Vrbo and Google to ensure a well-rounded perspective on guest satisfaction. Company must have at least 2 platforms connected and a minimum of 4.0 stars on each platform.
  • Homeowner Reviews: Direct feedback from homeowners provides valuable insights into the manager's performance from the owner's perspective. A minimum of 5 reviews is required and a minimum of a 4.0 star rating.
  • Performance Metrics: Transparency is key. Managers who actively fill out our PM Supplied Metrics section demonstrate a commitment to data-driven decision making.
  • Market Presence: Market leaders establish a strong foothold in their local area. In order to be eligible for an award, company must have a local presence and a minimum of 10 properties under management in that specific market.

Beyond the Basics: Scoring Excellence (Weighted)

  • Guest Review Score: We factor in the average score from verified guest reviews across different platforms, weighted at 50%.
  • Owner Review Score: The homeowner experience matters. We also consider the average score from owner reviews, weighted at 50%.

We update our data and scoring methodology regularly to ensure it reflects the evolving vacation rental landscape. If data from a manager is unavailable, we'll clearly communicate this and explain any adjustments made to the scoring process.

FAQs

The Comparent Score is calculated with a formula that takes the average of all guest reviews plus the owner review score and multiplies by 10.

Determining the best vacation rental management company depends on a variety of factors including reviews, performance, and industry impact. These elements collectively influence which company will best serve your business's specific needs and expectations. Comparent simplifies the search process and provides an extensive platform where you can easily browse and find the top vacation rental management companies in your market.

Vacation rental managers distribute review links to their property owners via email or within owner statements. Comparent also proactively contacts homeowners via email, guiding them to the platform. Whether seeking management services or already partnered with a professional management company listed on Comparent, homeowners are invited to submit reviews for any companies they have experience with.

Make sure you have a complete profile with a detailed description highlighting your strengths, markets served, and FAQs. A minimum of 4.0-star ratings on Google, Airbnb, and VRBO is required, and securing at least 5 reviews from owners can make a big difference. If you need help updating your profile, contact us at support@comparent.com.

Behind the Numbers: Identifying the Industry Market Leaders

The Importance of a Comprehensive Profile

A comprehensive profile is vital for showcasing the vacation rental management company's expertise and fostering trust with homeowners. A complete profile should be detailed and cover the company's history, mission, values, and key achievements. The profile should also include informative FAQs and a clear outline of the services offered. A thorough and transparent profile helps inform potential clients and builds confidence in the company's ability to effectively manage and enhance vacation rental properties.

A manager's Comparent profile, showing description, services and FAQs

Homeowner Testimonials

Owner reviews provide essential insights into the performance of a vacation rental management company from the owner's perspective. To ensure a holistic evaluation, a minimum of 5 reviews, each with at least a 4.0-star rating is required. Homeowner reviews highlight various aspects of the company's credibility and reliability, providing a well-rounded assessment. This type of feedback also allows the management company to identify areas of improvement and continue to enhance their services and exceed expectations.

Homeowner testimonials on a manager's profile
Guest review scores from Airbnb, Vrbo and Google

Multi-channel Guest Reviews

Reviews from multiple trusted platforms such as Airbnb, VRBO, and Google provide a balanced perspective on guest satisfaction.

  1. The vacation rental management company must be connected to at least 2 major platforms and have a minimum rating of 4.0 stars on each to qualify.
  2. Collecting reviews from diverse sources ensures an understanding of the company's performance indicating its broad reach and accessibility.
  3. High ratings reflect quality and commitment to excellence.

Metrics Of Success

Transparency in performance metrics is vital. Managers who actively update and share metrics such as occupancy rates, average daily rates, and other scores not only help themselves but also potential clients measure success. This approach encourages continuous improvement and strengthens accountability.

Industry Footprint

Market leaders in vacation rental management establish a significant presence in their local area. In order to qualify, a company must have a solid footprint in its market and manage a minimum of 10 properties in that specific market. This demonstrates the company's ability to understand and serve local dynamics and preferences. Engaging with the community further amplifies its reputation and strengthens its role as a trusted leader in the industry.

Check STR regulations before choosing your next property manager

Explore STR Regulations