Comparent
Nightly Rental Management logo

Nightly Rental Management

Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent
Headquarters
Springfield, Missouri, 65806
Founded in
2022
Full-time employees
10
Total managed properties
19
Markets served
5
  • Owner5.0Owner: 10 reviews
  • 4.9Airbnb: 777 reviews
  • 4.8Vrbo: 186 reviews
  • 5.0Google: 506 reviews

Who is Nightly Rental Management?

Nightly Rental Management is a vacation rental management company based in Springfield, MO, founded in 2022. It manages 19 properties across five locations, including Pensacola, FL, and Branson, MO. It has a 5 rating on Owner from 10 reviews, a 4.9 rating on Airbnb from 777 reviews, a 4.8 rating on Vrbo from 186 reviews, and a 5 rating on Google from 506 reviews.

Source: summary written by Comparent from the facts on this page; description written by the company.

In Nightly Rental Management’s own words

Written by Nightly Rental Management

Maximize Returns. Minimize Worry.

You didn’t invest in a property to become a full-time operator. You want strong performance, happy guests, and your time back. That’s where we come in.

At Nightly, we’re a full-service short-term rental management company that helps intentional investors like you earn more with less stress. From bookings and guest communication to cleaning, accounting, and maintenance—we handle it all with excellence and transparency.

We don’t just promise results—we back them. Our bold 5/5/5 Guarantee means we’re accountable for 5-star reviews, property protection, and lightning-fast onboarding. It’s how we deliver peace of mind and real performance, every single stay.

Our mission is to redefine hospitality by cultivating trust and maximizing returns. When you partner with Nightly, your property does more than perform—it reflects your values.

Where does Nightly Rental Management manage vacation rentals?

In 5 places: Pensacola (2 properties), Branson (8 properties), Hollister (2 properties), Ozark (2 properties), and Springfield (5 properties). Its headquarters is in Springfield, MO.

2 properties in Florida

Source: places and property counts reported by the company.

How do homeowners rate Nightly Rental Management?

5 out of 5 from 10 homeowner reviews on Comparent; 4.9 on Airbnb (777); 4.8 on Vrbo (186); 5 on Google (506).

  • Owner5.0Owner: 10 reviews
  • 4.9Airbnb: 777 reviews
  • 4.8Vrbo: 186 reviews
  • 5.0Google: 506 reviews

Source: homeowner reviews collected on Comparent; other ratings collected by Comparent from those sites. As of: latest homeowner review May 9, 2025; Airbnb, Vrbo, and Google ratings collected Nov 2026.

5.0

Owner’s rating from 10 reviews

Cleanliness
5.0 out of 5, from 10 reviews
Financial
5.0 out of 5, from 10 reviews
Maintenance
5.0 out of 5, from 10 reviews
Responsiveness
5.0 out of 5, from 10 reviews
Service
5.0 out of 5, from 10 reviews

Your trust is our highest priority. Our reviews are genuine and unbiased — companies cannot pay to modify or remove them.

10 reviews

  • Brooke P.

    May 9, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    In just 6 months Nightly has not only impressed us but successfully turned our rental unit around. We are extremely pleased with their effectiveness and customer care.

  • Brooke P.

    May 9, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    Partnering with Nightly has been a great experience as an investor. They’re highly responsive, communicate proactively, and understand the financial metrics, while staying focused on providing a positive experience for guests. This is often reflected in our property’s reviews. If you’re looking for a management partner who thinks like an investor, I couldn’t recommend Nightly more.

  • Brooke P.

    May 9, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    They've made all of the decisions super easy. That's the best part about working with these guys—I don't have to worry about anything; I get a check once a month. If that's what you're looking for, Nightly is the place you want to be.

  • Zac L.

    May 9, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    Nightly Rental is the best property management company I have ever worked with. They consistently exceed our expectations. I recommend them to anyone looking for STR management.

  • Kandi S.

    April 29, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    When you find someone who cares for your property like it’s their own, you know you’re in the right hands! We could not be more pleased with the service Nightly provides!

Can I trust Nightly Rental Management?

Comparent verified Nightly Rental Management's identity. It lists 2 memberships, including Airbnb Superhost and Vrbo Premier Partner.

Verified by Comparent
Comparent confirmed this company's identity and that the person managing the profile works there.
Granted by Comparent
Airbnb Superhost
Declared by the company
Vrbo Premier Partner
Declared by the company

Source: verification and awards by Comparent; memberships as declared by Nightly Rental Management. Meanings written by Comparent.

What does Nightly Rental Management do for owners?

Nightly Rental Management says 12 services in all.

  • Trust Accounting
  • Property Inspections
  • Revenue Management/Dynamic Pricing
  • Local Ownership
  • Guest Screening/ID Verification
  • Guest Damage Insurance/Security Deposit Insurance Program
  • Local Support 24/7
  • Tax Compliance and Remittance
  • In-house Cleaning
  • Keyless Entry Provided
  • SmartHome
  • Unlimited Owner Use

Source: services the company says it offers. Definitions written by Comparent, the same on every profile.

How big is Nightly Rental Management's business?

Nightly Rental Management manages about 19 properties, as reported by the company, with a team of 10 full-time employees.

Reported by the property manager, not independently verified.

Active properties
37

Property types

Property types
  • Homes51%
  • Condos43%
  • Other5%

Bedroom mix

Bedroom mix
  • 1 bed8%
  • 2 bed30%
  • 3 bed30%
  • 4 bed16%
  • 5 bed11%
  • 6+ bed5%
Active properties
40
Reviews per property
14.2

Property types

Property types
  • Homes45%
  • Condos38%
  • Other18%

Bedroom mix

Bedroom mix
  • 1 bed25%
  • 2 bed28%
  • 3 bed28%
  • 4 bed10%
  • 5 bed3%
  • 6+ bed8%
Active properties
40
Reviews per property
2.2

Property types

Property types
  • Homes45%
  • Condos38%
  • Other18%

Bedroom mix

Bedroom mix
  • 1 bed25%
  • 2 bed28%
  • 3 bed28%
  • 4 bed10%
  • 5 bed3%
  • 6+ bed8%

The metrics and data displayed above are sourced from publicly available information. While Comparent strives to ensure that this information is reliable, please note that the data is not guaranteed for accuracy and should be independently verified. We disclaim any liability for any inaccuracies or omissions in these metrics.

Source: figures reported by Nightly Rental Management; review counts collected by Comparent from Airbnb, Vrbo and Google.

Questions Nightly Rental Management hasn't answered yet

Nightly Rental Management hasn’t claimed this listing yet, so it hasn’t given Comparent these answers. You can ask in your message, or compare other managers who have.

Who will I work with at Nightly Rental Management?
No named contact listed.

How do I contact Nightly Rental Management?

Send a message with the form below. Nightly Rental Management will see your name, email and message and reply to you directly.

Go to the message form

More questions about Nightly Rental Management

Nightly Rental Management’s own answers, all open.

1. Commission & Costs: Please explain your commission structure and any additional costs a homeowner might incur.

We believe your investment should work for you—not the other way around. That’s why our management fee is based on net commissionable revenue—meaning we don’t charge commission on Airbnb or OTA fees. You only pay based on the income that actually reaches your pocket.

We offer a competitive rate tailored to the unique strengths of your property, and we’re fully transparent about any additional costs. From day one, our goal is to help you maximize returns while keeping your experience hands-off and hassle-free.

2. Marketing: Please detail the strategies you utilize to market properties to guests.

You’ve made a smart investment—our job is to help it outperform. We syndicate your property to top platforms like Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, and Google Vacation Rentals to maximize exposure and bookings.

Our team is well-versed in the tactics that influence OTA algorithms—from photo sequencing and title structure to calendar nudges and review velocity. We optimize listings with the goal of earning higher search placement, more reservations, 5 star reviews, and ultimately more bookings. It’s not just set-and-forget—we know how to work with the algorithm to keep your property visible and competitive.With added exposure from social media, your property is built to perform.

The result? Our listings outperformed other professional managers in our markets by 24% in 2023.

3. Cleaning & Maintenance: Please outline your property management services, including but not limited to cleaning, inspections and maintenance.

Your property is an investment—you shouldn’t have to worry about whether it’s being properly cared for between guests. Our team manages every detail of cleaning, supply restocking, and overall upkeep to keep your home consistently guest-ready.

Our property stewardship team ensures that issues are addressed quickly and proactively—so small problems don’t become big ones. We follow detailed checklists, conduct regular inspections, and hold all vendors to high standards to deliver a consistently excellent guest experience.

With our 5-star stay guarantee, your guests enjoy a flawless stay—and you enjoy peace of mind knowing your property is in good hands.

5. Financial Management: Please discuss how you handle financial management for the properties you manage. Do you follow trust accounting principles?

We believe financial stewardship builds trust—and trust builds long-term success. That’s why we follow strict trust accounting principles and manage every dollar with transparency and care.

Our accounting team brings decades of experience in short-term rental trust accounting, and we use industry-standard ERP software to ensure every cent is tracked accurately and allocated correctly across each property.

Owners receive a clear, easy-to-read monthly statement that details revenue, expenses, and distributions—so you always know how your investment is performing. No guesswork, just dependable reporting you can count on.

6. Technology: What kind of technology do you employ and how does this technology provide benefits to both homeowners and guests?

We believe technology should enhance both guest experience and owner confidence. With a co-founder who is a former Fortune 100 software engineer, Nightly was built on smart, scalable systems that drive performance at every level.

We use smart locks with time-bound, reservation-specific codes to ensure seamless access and enhanced security. Each guest receives a customized digital guidebook with property information, amenities, FAQs, and curated local recommendations to elevate their stay.

We’re continually evaluating and adopting emerging technologies to stay ahead of industry trends—ensuring your property stays competitive and your experience stays effortless.

7. Differentiators: What unique aspects set your company apart from other property management companies, especially in terms of advantages to homeowners?

At Nightly, we’re redefining hospitality with a bold promise to intentional investors: our 5/5/5 Guarantee. That means:

  • 5-Star Guarantee – If a guest leaves anything less, we waive our management fee.
  • $5 Million in Property Protection – Peace of mind, five million strong.
  • 5-Day Onboarding – or your first month free, so your investment starts working for you faster.

We don’t take on every property—only those we believe can consistently meet our high standard for 5-star reviews in cleanliness, accuracy, and communication. Because your reputation and returns are worth protecting.

Backed by advanced guest screening, dynamic pricing, and a hands-on local team, we help you maximize your investment while building long-term trust.

8. Guest Damage: What is your approach to managing damages caused by guests? Do you require a security deposit or offer damage insurance? If you opt for insurance, how do you establish the coverage details?

We take protecting your property seriously. That’s why every stay is backed by $5 million in guest damage protection, covering accidental or intentional damage caused by guests. This isn’t optional—it’s included automatically to protect your asset, not just ours.

We also apply unmatched guest screening. Each guest is personally vetted and then independently verified using sophisticated screening software across all booking channels. This proactive approach significantly reduces risk and ensures we host only qualified, trustworthy guests.

Our goal is simple: deliver exceptional stays while safeguarding the value of your investment.

9. Revenue Management: Please explain your strategy for revenue management? How do you determine pricing to optimize earnings? Do you utilize dynamic pricing software, manage rates manually, or employ a combination of both methods?

You’ve invested in a high-performing property—our job is to help it reach its full earning potential. That’s why we’ve brought on an in-house data analyst who specializes in outperforming the market using professional-grade pricing software and real-time demand data.

We craft pricing strategies daily based on seasonality, local trends, booking curves, and competitor performance. This approach helped our investors outperform other professional managers by 24% in 2024—and we’ve never lost an investor to another management company due to underperformance.

Because when your property thrives, your portfolio grows—and that’s what we’re here for.

10. Community Involvement and Reputation: Are you involved in the local community and do you support local initiatives?

As an intentional investor, you care about more than just returns—you want your property to create lasting impact. At Nightly, we share that vision.

We reinvest 10% of our net operating income into the communities where your properties operate, aligning your investment with local good and long-term value. For us, giving back isn’t just a gesture—it’s an expression of our identity.

Our Core Focus is clear:

Passion: Helping people experience their vision and potential

Niche: Redefining hospitality, cultivating trust, and maximizing returns

We live this out by showing up—not just for guests and owners, but for neighbors, nonprofits, and local partnerships. When you choose Nightly, you’re not only optimizing your property—you’re investing in a team that believes:

  • Cultivate Trust at All Levels
  • Relationships Matter
  • Go Above and Beyond
  • Passionate People in their Sweet Spots
  • Work Hard and Play Hard

Partnering with Nightly means your investment aligns with something bigger than bookings—it’s a force for good in the places we call home.

Source: answers written by Nightly Rental Management.

Send a message to Nightly Rental Management.

Nightly Rental Management will see your name, email and message, and will reply to you directly.