
Elite Lake Rentals
- Headquarters
- Lake Geneva, Wisconsin, 53147
- Founded in
- 2021
- Full-time employees
- 3
- Total managed properties
- 20
- Markets served
- 5
- 4.9Google: 15 reviews
Who is Elite Lake Rentals?
Elite Lake Rentals is a vacation rental management company based in Lake Geneva, WI. It manages 20 properties across Lake Geneva, WI, Lauderdale Lakes, WI, and Powers Lake, WI. It has a 4.9 rating on Google from 15 reviews.
Source: summary written by Comparent from the facts on this page; description written by the company.
In Elite Lake Rentals’s own words
Written by Elite Lake Rentals
Elite Lake Rentals is a family-owned, full-service vacation rental management company based in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin. We specialize in short-term rental homes on or near the lakes throughout Walworth and Kenosha Counties.
We carefully select the homes in our portfolio to reflect our commitment to quality, comfort, and exceptional hospitality. Led by husband-and-wife team Jason and Heather Smolarek, our local team combines extensive hospitality experience with hands-on care and personal attention.
From marketing and revenue management to guest service, housekeeping, and year-round property care, we handle the details so homeowners can enjoy the benefits of ownership. We focus on delivering five-star guest experiences, maximizing rental revenue, and keeping your home well cared for throughout the year.
Get in touch to learn how your property can become part of the Elite Lake Rentals portfolio.
Where does Elite Lake Rentals manage vacation rentals?
In 3 places in Wisconsin: Lake Geneva (17 properties), Lauderdale Lakes (1 property), and Powers Lake (2 properties). Its headquarters is in Lake Geneva, WI.
20 properties in Wisconsin
Source: places and property counts reported by the company.
How do homeowners rate Elite Lake Rentals?
4.9 on Google (15).
- 4.9Google: 15 reviews
Source: homeowner reviews collected on Comparent; other ratings collected by Comparent from those sites. As of: Google rating collected Nov 2026.
No homeowner has reviewed Elite Lake Rentals on Comparent yet.
Write the first reviewCan I trust Elite Lake Rentals?
Comparent verified Elite Lake Rentals's identity. It lists 5 memberships, including Airbnb Superhost and Breezeway Safety Certified.
- Verified by Comparent
- Comparent confirmed this company's identity and that the person managing the profile works there.
- Granted by Comparent
Airbnb Superhost- Declared by the company
Breezeway Safety Certified- Declared by the company
National Association of Realtors- Declared by the company
Vrbo Premier Partner- Declared by the company
VRMA Member- Declared by the company
Source: verification and awards by Comparent; memberships as declared by Elite Lake Rentals. Meanings written by Comparent.
What does Elite Lake Rentals do for owners?
Elite Lake Rentals says 13 services in all.
- Trust Accounting
- Property Inspections
- Revenue Management/Dynamic Pricing
- Local Ownership
- Guest Screening/ID Verification
- Guest Damage Insurance/Security Deposit Insurance Program
- Local Support 24/7
- Tax Compliance and Remittance
- Commercial Laundry
- In-house Cleaning
- Keyless Entry Provided
- SmartHome
- Unlimited Owner Use
Source: services the company says it offers. Definitions written by Comparent, the same on every profile.
How big is Elite Lake Rentals's business?
Elite Lake Rentals manages about 20 properties, as reported by the company, with a team of 3 full-time employees.
Reported by the property manager, not independently verified.
- Active properties
- 21
- Average annual daily rate
- $628
- Average annual occupancy
- 35%
- Direct bookings
- 50%
Property types
- Homes95%
- Condos5%
Bedroom mix
- 2 bed10%
- 3 bed38%
- 4 bed43%
- 5 bed10%
The metrics and data displayed above are sourced from publicly available information. While Comparent strives to ensure that this information is reliable, please note that the data is not guaranteed for accuracy and should be independently verified. We disclaim any liability for any inaccuracies or omissions in these metrics.
Source: figures reported by Elite Lake Rentals; review counts collected by Comparent from Airbnb, Vrbo and Google.
Questions Elite Lake Rentals hasn't answered yet
Elite Lake Rentals hasn’t claimed this listing yet, so it hasn’t given Comparent these answers. You can ask in your message, or compare other managers who have.
- Who will I work with at Elite Lake Rentals?
- No named contact listed.
How do I contact Elite Lake Rentals?
Send a message with the form below. Elite Lake Rentals will see your name, email and message and reply to you directly.
Go to the message formMore questions about Elite Lake Rentals
Elite Lake Rentals’s own answers, all open.
1. Commission & Costs: Please explain your commission structure and any additional costs a homeowner might incur.
Our full-service management fees typically range from 20% to 30% of gross rental revenue. We evaluate each home’s location, size, condition, amenities, and rental potential, along with the homeowner’s planned personal use, particularly during peak season, to provide a customized proposal with a clear commission rate.
Each calendar year, we review the rate based on the property’s actual gross rental revenue from the prior year.
Additional homeowner costs may include initial deep cleaning, linen pool setup, required permits and licenses, a smart lock, maintenance, repairs, and replacement supplies. We outline anticipated costs in your proposal and review them during onboarding so you understand what it takes to prepare and maintain your home for successful rentals.
2. Marketing: Please detail the strategies you utilize to market properties to guests.
We market each home across Airbnb, Vrbo, Booking.com, Expedia, Google Travel, Rentalz, and our direct booking website. Professional photography, detailed descriptions, and carefully presented amenities help guests understand what makes each property special.
We also promote our portfolio through social media, email marketing, identity resolution, targeted digital advertising, local publications, and community relationships. Our local platforms, including LakeGeneva.ai and Delavan.ai, provide additional opportunities to connect with travelers researching the area. Repeat guest offers and direct booking campaigns help build returning business.
3. Cleaning & Maintenance: Please outline your property management services, including but not limited to cleaning, inspections and maintenance.
We manage housekeeping, linen service, inspections, maintenance coordination, and weekly garbage bin service, including taking bins to the curb and returning them after collection.
Our inspection process includes checks after guest departure, after cleaning, and before arrival to identify damage, verify cleanliness, and ensure the home is ready for the next guest. Our linen program uses commercial laundering for a consistent guest experience.
We coordinate routine repairs and local service providers, identify preventative maintenance needs, and address issues during stays. Year-round, we inspect unoccupied homes every 10 days and after storms to help catch problems early and protect the property between stays.
5. Financial Management: Please discuss how you handle financial management for the properties you manage. Do you follow trust accounting principles?
We use Streamline’s dedicated vacation rental accounting platform to manage reservation payments, property-level income and expenses, management fees, and owner statements. Its trust accounting capabilities support the separation and tracking of funds belonging to guests and homeowners.
Owner statements provide an itemized view of rental activity, fees, expenses, and owner proceeds. This gives homeowners a clear record of how their property is performing and how funds are allocated.
6. Technology: What kind of technology do you employ and how does this technology provide benefits to both homeowners and guests?
We use enterprise-level property management software to coordinate reservations, synchronize calendars across booking platforms, manage guest communications, and support trust accounting and owner reporting.
Our technology also includes dynamic pricing software, keyless smart locks, noise monitoring, a custom guest app, and an owner dashboard. Guests benefit from convenient arrival access and readily available property information. Homeowners benefit from better visibility into their investment, coordinated operations, and technology that helps us respond to property concerns.
7. Differentiators: What unique aspects set your company apart from other property management companies, especially in terms of advantages to homeowners?
Elite Lake Rentals combines hands-on local ownership with experience managing vacation rentals at a national scale. Jason and Heather Smolarek bring a hospitality management background and leadership experience with companies including Wyndham/ResortQuest, Southern Vacation Rentals, Vacasa, and Kasa.
We apply that experience through a boutique approach: direct access to ownership, multiple inspections between stays, consistent linen standards, and ongoing care when homes are vacant. We live and work in the Lake Geneva area, know the local market, and focus on protecting each home while building sustainable rental income.
8. Guest Damage: What is your approach to managing damages caused by guests? Do you require a security deposit or offer damage insurance? If you opt for insurance, how do you establish the coverage details?
Every reservation includes a damage waiver with up to $1 million in general liability coverage, $1 million in bodily injury coverage, $10,000 in accidental damage coverage, and $15,000 in bedbug remediation coverage, including lost income, subject to applicable policy terms and exclusions.
Our post-departure inspections help identify damage promptly. When an issue occurs, we document it, coordinate repairs or remediation, and manage the claim process on the homeowner’s behalf. We review coverage details with homeowners during onboarding so they understand the protection provided.
9. Revenue Management: Please explain your strategy for revenue management? How do you determine pricing to optimize earnings? Do you utilize dynamic pricing software, manage rates manually, or employ a combination of both methods?
We combine dynamic pricing software with hands-on rate management and local market knowledge. We evaluate comparable properties, seasonal demand, local events, booking pace, lead time, and each home’s amenities and location.
We regularly review rates and adjust minimum stays, gap-night availability, and promotions as needed. Our goal is to maximize total rental revenue while balancing occupancy, nightly rates, and the costs associated with frequent turnovers.
10. Community Involvement and Reputation: Are you involved in the local community and do you support local initiatives?
We live and work in the community we serve. We participate in Lake Geneva’s Short-Term Rental Ad Hoc Committee, representing professional vacation rental management and contributing practical input on local ordinance changes.
Our memberships include the Walworth County Chamber, Lake Geneva Business Improvement District, Vacation Rental Management Association, and Wisconsin Short-Term Rental Alliance. We also own LakeGeneva.ai, an AI-powered local business network that helps connect residents and visitors with area businesses. Through local vendor relationships and responsible guest management, we support the community while helping homeowners operate successful vacation rentals.
Source: answers written by Elite Lake Rentals.