Comparent

Vacation rental management companies in Southold, NY

Comparent lists 9 vacation rental management companies serving Southold, New York, and 6 are verified. A typical company here manages 332 homes in total.

Updated Sources: company-reported portfolios, Airbnb, Vrbo and Google ratings, Comparent owner reviewsHow we rank

Filters

City
Homeowner reviews
Airbnb rating
Vrbo rating
Google rating

All 9 companies serving Southold

Showing 1–9 of 9 managers

  1. Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent

    Founded In 2008

    Manages 4,005 properties

    Headquarters
    Knoxville, TN
    Also in
    Connecticut Coast, CT
    • No Homeowner reviews rating yet
    • Airbnb rating 4.8 out of 5 from 16,024 reviews
    • Vrbo rating 4.8 out of 5 from 23,129 reviews
    • Google rating 4.7 out of 5 from 2,233 reviews

    iTrip® was created in 2008 when founders Steve Presley, Todd Morrison and Tom Bissmeyer - each an owner of short-term rental properties - realized both property owners and guests needed a higher level of service than what was…View full profile of iTrip Corporate (opens in a new tab)

    • 2026 Comparent 100
    • The Comparent 100 Page
  2. Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent

    Founded In 2008

    Headquarters
    Lehi, UT
    Also in
    Southold, NY
    • No Homeowner reviews rating yet
    • Airbnb rating 4.9 out of 5 from 4,286 reviews
    • Vrbo rating 4.8 out of 5 from 596 reviews
    • Google rating 4.5 out of 5 from 5,069 reviews

    Property Management Inc. provides expert property management services and solutions across five pillars: residential, multifamily, commercial, association, and short-term rental management. These five pillars of property management…View full profile of Property Management Inc. (opens in a new tab)

    • 2026 Comparent 100
    • The Comparent 100 Page
  3. Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent

    Founded In 2007

    Manages 202 properties

    Headquarters
    New York, NY
    Also in
    East Hampton, NY
    Employees
    35
    • Homeowner reviews rating 5.0 out of 5 from 7 reviews
    • Airbnb rating 4.9 out of 5 from 2,869 reviews
    • Vrbo rating 4.8 out of 5 from 133 reviews
    • Google rating 4.7 out of 5 from 161 reviews

    Red Cottage is the leader in booking and management for unique and well-designed vacation rentals across the Northeast.

  4. Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent

    Manages 461 properties

    Headquarters
    Melville, NY
    Also in
    Sag Harbor, NY
    • No Homeowner reviews rating yet
    • Airbnb rating 4.6 out of 5 from 1,278 reviews
    • Google rating 4.4 out of 5 from 56 reviews
  5. Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent

    Founded In 2024

    Manages 4 properties

    Headquarters
    Chestertown, NY
    Also in
    East Hampton, NY
    • No Homeowner reviews rating yet

    At Abode Away Properties, we specialize in short-term rentals, turning your home into a high-performing investment — without the stress of managing it yourself. Whether you own a vacation home, an income property, or a second…View full profile of Abode Away Properties (opens in a new tab)

Southold vacation rental market in numbers

Companies on Comparent report an average of $1,109 a night at 17.0% occupancy on Airbnb (461 homes).

Totalled across the Airbnb and Vrbo listings of the companies on Comparent in Southold. Homeowner rating average 5.00; Google 4.69. How we rank
SoutholdAirbnbVrbo
Homes listed by companies on Comparent461Not reported
Average nightly rate$1,109Not reported
Average occupancy17.0%Not reported
Houses / condos93% / 0%Not reported
Most common size4 bedrooms (31%)Not reported
Average company rating4.794.79

Questions about vacation rental managers in Southold

How many vacation rental management companies are there in Southold, NY?

Comparent lists 9 companies serving Southold; 6 are verified (November 2026).

How much do vacation rentals earn in Southold?

Homes run by companies on Comparent average $1,109 a night at 17.0% occupancy on Airbnb.