
Cottages to Castles
- Headquarters
- Sanibel, Florida
- Founded in
- 1997
- Full-time employees
- 2
- Total managed properties
- 40
- Markets served
- 3
Who is Cottages to Castles?
Cottages to Castles is a vacation rental management company based in Sanibel, FL. It manages 40 properties across Sanibel, FL. The company has 2 full-time employees.
Source: summary written by Comparent from the facts on this page; description written by the company.
In Cottages to Castles’s own words
Written by Cottages to Castles
About Cottages to Castles
A Legacy Built on Southern Hospitality & Island Expertise
Cottages to Castles was founded in 1997 by the mother-daughter team of Judy and Sharon Michie—pioneers who created Sanibel and Captiva's first boutique vacation rental agency dedicated exclusively to rentals, not sales. Their vision was simple yet revolutionary: treat every property owner as a partner and every guest as family.
Judy Michie, affectionately known as the "Grand Dame of Rentals," began her vacation rental career on the islands in 1983. Her commitment to personalized service was so legendary that she was awarded Sanibel Captiva Realtor of the Year by her peers—without ever selling a single property. Judy raised five children in a 1946 Fort Myers Beach cottage and helped transform Lee County into a premier tourist destination.
Her daughter Sharon joined the business after graduating from Cornell University's School of Hospitality Management and gaining valuable experience in the hotel industry. Together, they built Cottages to Castles on a foundation of true Southern hospitality, meticulous property care, and relationships that turned first-time guests into decades-long friends.
When Judy passed away in 2015, Sharon continued their shared legacy with the same warmth, dedication, and expertise that defined their partnership.
Sharon Michie | Owner & Broker
For nearly three decades, Sharon has been Sanibel and Captiva's go-to vacation rental specialist. As a Licensed Florida Real Estate Broker, Certified Guest Service Professional, and trusted community leader, she brings unparalleled local knowledge and hospitality training to every guest experience.
Sharon's expertise extends beyond vacation rentals—she regularly advises fellow Realtors and Brokers whose clients are considering island property purchases. Her advice? "Before you buy an island home, rent. After you buy an island home, rent it!"
A Sanibel native, Sharon lives and breathes island life. She's an outdoor enthusiast who enjoys fishing, boating, cycling, and running half-marathons with friends and family. In her youth, she was a nationally #1 ranked cyclist and Lee County Spelling Bee Champion—passions she still follows closely through the Tour de France and Scripps National Spelling Bee with e-n-t-h-u-s-i-a-s-m!
Our Commitment to Excellence - The C2C Difference
Since 1997, Cottages to Castles has set the standard for boutique vacation rental management on Sanibel and Captiva. We've built our reputation on:
✓ Nearly 30 years of trusted, personalized service
✓ Breezeway Certified Safety Inspectors ensuring every property meets rigorous standards
✓ Certified Guest Service Professionals dedicated to exceeding client and guest expectations with every interaction
✓ Deep island roots and local connections that turn good vacations into unforgettable experiences
✓ Owner-first approach treating your investment with the care it deserves
The Cottages to Castles Team takes safety and service seriously. Our certifications aren't just credentials—they're our commitment to delivering peace of mind with every stay.
Giving Back to Our Community
Sharon and the Cottages to Castles team are deeply involved in the Sanibel and Captiva community:
- Active member, Sanibel Captiva Vacation Rental Managers Association
- Volunteer, Sanibel Chapter of the American Legion Auxiliary Girls State program
- Member, Cornell Club of Southwest Florida
- Affiliate Member, Sanibel-Captiva Board of Realtors
- Volunteer with F.I.S.H. of Sanibel (Social Services/Community Food Bank)
- Supporter of Sanibel Captiva Conservation Foundation, C.R.O.W. Animal Hospital, and Keep Lee County Beautiful
Through hurricanes, recovery, and growth, we've remained committed to the island community we love and the families who trust us with their vacation dreams.
Welcome Home to Sanibel & Captiva
Whether you're searching for your perfect island retreat or seeking expert management for your vacation property, Sharon and the Cottages to Castles Team are here to help. We look forward to welcoming you to our beautiful corner of the world!
Where does Cottages to Castles manage vacation rentals?
In 1 place in Florida: Sanibel (40 properties). Its headquarters is in Sanibel, FL.
40 properties in Florida
Source: places and property counts reported by the company.
Can I trust Cottages to Castles?
Comparent verified Cottages to Castles's identity. It lists 2 memberships, including Breezeway Safety Certified and Vrbo Premier Partner.
- Verified by Comparent
- Comparent confirmed this company's identity and that the person managing the profile works there.
- Granted by Comparent
Breezeway Safety Certified- Declared by the company
Vrbo Premier Partner- Declared by the company
Source: verification and awards by Comparent; memberships as declared by Cottages to Castles. Meanings written by Comparent.
What does Cottages to Castles do for owners?
Cottages to Castles says 13 services in all.
- Trust Accounting
- Property Inspections
- Revenue Management/Dynamic Pricing
- Local Ownership
- Guest Screening/ID Verification
- Guest Damage Insurance/Security Deposit Insurance Program
- Local Support 24/7
- Tax Compliance and Remittance
- In-house Cleaning
- Keyless Entry Provided
- SmartHome
- No Startup Fees
- Unlimited Owner Use
Source: services the company says it offers. Definitions written by Comparent, the same on every profile.
How big is Cottages to Castles's business?
Cottages to Castles manages about 40 properties, as reported by the company, with a team of 2 full-time employees.
Reported by the property manager, not independently verified.
- Active properties
- 40
- Average annual occupancy
- 63%
- Direct bookings
- 80%
- Average guest response time
- 5 minutes
Property types
- Homes38%
- Condos46%
- Other15%
Bedroom mix
- 1 bed18%
- 2 bed38%
- 3 bed41%
- 4 bed3%
The metrics and data displayed above are sourced from publicly available information. While Comparent strives to ensure that this information is reliable, please note that the data is not guaranteed for accuracy and should be independently verified. We disclaim any liability for any inaccuracies or omissions in these metrics.
Source: figures reported by Cottages to Castles; review counts collected by Comparent from Airbnb, Vrbo and Google.
Questions Cottages to Castles hasn't answered yet
Cottages to Castles hasn’t claimed this listing yet, so it hasn’t given Comparent these answers. You can ask in your message, or compare other managers who have.
- How do homeowners rate Cottages to Castles?
- Cottages to Castles hasn't answered this yet.
- Who will I work with at Cottages to Castles?
- No named contact listed.
How do I contact Cottages to Castles?
Send a message with the form below. Cottages to Castles will see your name, email and message and reply to you directly.
Go to the message formMore questions about Cottages to Castles
Cottages to Castles’s own answers, all open.
1. Commission & Costs: Please explain your commission structure and any additional costs a homeowner might incur.
- Our commission rates are competitive, although that alone should not be a deciding factor when partnering with an agency. The level of services that we provide is not tiered into a variable commission rate like some agencies offer.
- We do not offer cafeteria style rates. Our rate gives you full access to our services, as well as our decades of experience, and you can't really put a dollar or percentage value on that.
- Two fee-based licenses are required to rent on Sanibel. An annual City Business Tax Receipt (BTR) and Dwelling Rental License (DRL) are required. A State License (no charge) and County License are required for the collection and submission of sales and bed tax on an owner's behalf. Elevated homes with 2+ stories require an annual balcony certification to be filed with the State of Florida.
- If an owner wishes to participate on the VRBO platform, we recommend an annual subscription package, not the fee-based pay-per-booking model. As a Premier Host, we can add a property within minutes and have it live, ready for reservations.
2. Marketing: Please detail the strategies you utilize to market properties to guests.
While many of our online and technology based marketing efforts are very similar to our on-island partner agencies, we do have have avenues that are proprietary to us that we use to leverage our presence in the marketplace.
The Cottages to Castles name and brand is established and well-known as a boutique agency. Many people are drawn to our name, especially when combing through the list of some fairly generic agency names. They'll click on our website link over another based on our name alone. How fun is that?
In addition, our on-island ground level office is in a prime location on Periwinkle Way, with a high volume of foot, bicycle and drive by traffic. We are easy to find, and guests frequently pop in looking or a place to stay, even if they are staying elsewhere on the island.
Our history and relationships with residents, business owners, realtors and visitors on the island are invaluable, and networking and referral opportunities present themselves often. It is these types of relationships that allow us to partner with each other for strong referral and word of mouth based business leads.
Our Christmas displays, Luminary gatherings and July 4 Parade parties are legendary, and they provide the perfect opportunity to welcome people (residents, renters, visitors, etc) to our little corner of the island for good cheer, mingling and a live-like-a-local good time.
3. Cleaning & Maintenance: Please outline your property management services, including but not limited to cleaning, inspections and maintenance.
We utilize smaller cleaning companies and individual, independent contractors at our properties. Owners are welcome to use the services of their own licensed private cleaner, provided their skills meet or exceed our cleanliness standards.
5. Financial Management: Please discuss how you handle financial management for the properties you manage. Do you follow trust accounting principles?
All owner and guest funds are placed in a designated Rents account, and best practices regarding Trust accounting principles are utilized. Accounts are reconciled monthly, and historical owner statements and records are available for owner inspection.
State Sales Taxes and Local Bed Taxes are collected and remitted to the appropriate agencies on a monthly basis, on behalf of each owner.
6. Technology: What kind of technology do you employ and how does this technology provide benefits to both homeowners and guests?
While we use cutting edge property management software that integrates dynamic pricing, integrated text and email communications, digital welcome books and more, our favorite use of technology is Smart Home Subscriptions to allow the use and control of remote locking systems, air conditioners, lighting, pool heaters and more. It's affordable and saves you money in time, insurance rates, hassle factor, safety and utility bills.
- Guests receive a unique key code to use during their stay, and they don't have to worry about carrying keys or returning them to the office. When they unlock the door, lights turn on and the air conditioning sets itself to a lower temperature. We can unlock the door remotely from a smart phone or computer if they have forgotten their code as well.
When the guest checks out, a code is sent to the housekeeper so that they can enter and begin to clean. No more waiting around or wondering when or if a guest has left. The housekeeper enters their unique code when they have finished cleaning and the status of your unit is changed online to "ready". We are notified, as is the guest, that the property is ready for them to come to our office to receive their check-in details and parking permit, etc.
- We can also create unique key codes for housekeepers, pest control, vendors (grocery, crib/high chair deliveries) or unlock doors remotely with the touch of a button. We are able to see who comes and goes, whether they used a code, if the door was unlocked remotely or if a key was used.
- There is restrictor on the air conditioning thermostat that will not allow a guest to set the temperature to a dangerously low level that could cause the air handler to freeze. We also use sensors on doors and windows, so that if they are left open for longer than 3 minutes, the air conditioning turns off. It will only turn back on when the door or window is closed.
This prevents after hours service calls for no a/c, and saves the owners money on avoidable service calls, repairs and replacement of equipment, while also realizing significant savings on monthly electric bills because doors and windows are not open while the a/c is running.
Properties are secure, we are able to see activity history, we can adjust pool heaters and thermostats remotely, and avoid costly service calls.
This smart home technology has been a game changer for guests, owners and our office.
- We also employ a text messaging communication system, along with a Digital Welcome Book. Guests can review the property-specific digital guide that we have created, with your specific wifi code, everything and anything about your property (pool service day, trash day, where the condo grills are, etc), as well as where to eat, dine, play, things to do on a rainy day with kids (or a pup) - it has everything to make guests feel like they are living like we do as locals.
The guests can text us questions about how something works, report something that needs attention or that a remote needs new batteries; and, we text guests to step outside and look up if they want to see a Falcon 9 rocket launch from Cape Canaveral (yes, we can see the launches here). We also use this technology to keep guests safe, particularly during severe thunderstorms or tropical storms where an emergency evacuation is not mandatory.
This technology was invaluable to us as we were evacuating guests in the days prior to Hurricane Ian impacting our area. We were able to keep them informed and let them know where to go, how to get there, and when our crews would be coming to secure their property.
In the weeks and months that followed, it was lovely to hear from guests asking how we are doing and checkin in on us.
Technology is fantastic when it enhances communications and brings a personal touch to the experience.
7. Differentiators: What unique aspects set your company apart from other property management companies, especially in terms of advantages to homeowners?
Cottages to Castles has been in business for 3 decades, and its founders have been in the rental business since 1981. We know the islands, we know its people, and we've been through the ups and downs of Bear and Bull markets, recessions, real estate booms and 4 hurricanes, 2 of which were Category 5s.
We work in partnership with our owners, and it's easy to appreciate each other when times are good. And while there is no better test of your relationship and trust for one another than after a natural disaster, there isn't a better agency than Cottages to Castles to be partnered with on the recovery side, representing your interests. Our Google Reviews are a testament to the level of service that you can expect to receive as an Owner when you partner with Cottages to Castles.
We live on the island, our building is on the island, we are "built" for a fast response, and we make sure that everything we do is to ensure the highest and best chance of survivability of our properties so that we can get back to renting sooner, rather than later.
Our skill, experience and knowledge in prepping properties pre-storm to post-storm recovery efforts are superior. Embracing technology such as Starlink satellite internet and voice-over-internet phone systems years before the 2022 hurricane meant that we were in touch with our owners and guests in real time, during the storm, and in the immediate aftermath, despite having no electricity for weeks off island and months on island.
We take our business personally, and we value our relationships with our owners and guests. Our job is to connect the dots so that your property is safe and offers a superior experience to guests that choose to rent it, so that their stay is a memorable one for all of the right reasons.
And, we like to have a lot of fun along the way. Won't you come and join us?
8. Guest Damage: What is your approach to managing damages caused by guests? Do you require a security deposit or offer damage insurance? If you opt for insurance, how do you establish the coverage details?
We offer damage protection insurance products in lieu of a substantial cash deposit during the reservation process, both online and in person.
We utilize software for housekeeping and maintenance to report damage and upload photographs in real time via a smartphone app.
9. Revenue Management: Please explain your strategy for revenue management? How do you determine pricing to optimize earnings? Do you utilize dynamic pricing software, manage rates manually, or employ a combination of both methods?
We utilize dynamic pricing blended with manual pricing based on our 30+ years of experience in the local market. Metrics vary and can impact properties that are zoned for nightly, weekly, bi-weekly and monthly stays, so the rates must be analyzed and applied to each property based on its zoning and minimum length of stay requirement as dictated by the City and County license that is assigned to it.
10. Community Involvement and Reputation: Are you involved in the local community and do you support local initiatives?
Our commitment to our community is founded in helping who you can, where you can, when you can. We are proud to be involved with organizations that support wildlife and the people who choose to live or work on these beautiful barrier islands.
One of the causes that is of importance to us is food insecurity in Southwest Florida. For over 30 years we have partnered with the Harry Chapin Foodbank (now F.I.S.H. of Sanibel) to donate all unopened food and sundry items that are left behind by guests - to the tune of over 10,000 pounds a year, so that those in need have access to food.
In addition, retired linens from our properties are donated to C.R.O.W. - our on island wildlife hospital. C.R.O.W. and the "Ding" Darling National Wildlife Refuge also receive donations of furnishings, household dishes and other items for their intern housing.
- Supporter and Volunteer at F.I.S.H. of Sanibel (Social Services)
- SCCF (Sanibel Captiva Conservation Foundation)
- Member of the Sanibel Captiva Island Board of Realtors
- Member American Legion Auxiliary of Sanibel-Captiva Post 123
- Cornell Club of SW Florida
- Treasurer, Sanibel Captiva Vacation Rental Manager Association
- FAVR member(Florida Association of Vacation Rentals
Source: answers written by Cottages to Castles.