Comparent
Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals logo

Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals

SponsoredVerified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent
  • 2026 Comparent 100
  • The Comparent 100 Page
Headquarters
Port St. Joe, Florida, 32456
Founded in
2002
Full-time employees
26
Total managed properties
346
Markets served
5
  • Owner5.0Owner: 7 reviews
  • 4.6Airbnb: 2,752 reviews
  • 4.5Vrbo: 1,985 reviews
  • 3.7Google: 220 reviews

Who is Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals?

Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals is a vacation rental management company based in Port St. Joe, Florida, founded in 2002. It manages 346 properties across Cape San Blas, Indian Pass, Mexico Beach, and Port St. Joe in Florida. It has a 5 rating from 7 owner reviews, a 4.6 rating on Airbnb from 2,752 reviews, a 4.5 rating on Vrbo from 1,985 reviews, and a 3.7 rating on Google from 220 reviews.

Source: summary written by Comparent from the facts on this page; description written by the company.

In Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals’s own words

Written by Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals

Formed in 2003 to service a small number of properties, this family owned and operated company has grown over the years to the largest property management company in the area managing nearly 250 properties. We are proud to represent the property owners and guests we’ve had over the years. Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals, carefully chose the starfish as the emblem to represent the 5 Star Property Management and Vacation Rentals organization they have created. The philosophy we operate under is simple – we are here to delight our homeowners and their guests. Your time in NW Florida is important to us! We want every guest to have the ultimate in relaxation on our pristine coastline.

We are serious about making you a satisfied Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals customer. We believe that higher quality can be delivered without higher costs and that premier service not only books the best homes but it brings in the best guests that come back year after year.

Where does Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals manage vacation rentals?

In 4 places in Florida: Cape San Blas (122 properties), Indian Pass (53 properties), Mexico Beach (75 properties), and Port St. Joe (28 properties). Its headquarters is in Port St. Joe, FL.

Source: places and property counts reported by the company.

How do homeowners rate Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals?

5 out of 5 from 7 homeowner reviews on Comparent; 4.6 on Airbnb (2752); 4.5 on Vrbo (1985); 3.7 on Google (220).

  • Owner5.0Owner: 7 reviews
  • 4.6Airbnb: 2,752 reviews
  • 4.5Vrbo: 1,985 reviews
  • 3.7Google: 220 reviews

Source: homeowner reviews collected on Comparent; other ratings collected by Comparent from those sites. As of: latest homeowner review April 30, 2025; Airbnb, Vrbo, and Google ratings collected Nov 2026.

5.0

Owner’s rating from 7 reviews

Cleanliness
5.0 out of 5, from 7 reviews
Financial
5.0 out of 5, from 7 reviews
Maintenance
5.0 out of 5, from 7 reviews
Responsiveness
5.0 out of 5, from 7 reviews
Service
5.0 out of 5, from 7 reviews

Your trust is our highest priority. Our reviews are genuine and unbiased — companies cannot pay to modify or remove them.

7 reviews

  • Kaylynn

    April 30, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    Pristine Properties is a household name around here, and for good reason! Their reputation is well-earned: extreme care for both us and our guests, and the properties are always kept pristine. The name says it all. It’s just great to know my property is in such capable and respected hands.

  • Michael

    April 30, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    I am a new owner (1 year) and live far away in Minnesota. I had a lot of anxiety about using a property manager for the first time, but I’m glad I chose Pristine! They answered all my questions throughout the first year and showed me there’s no need to worry. Thanks, Pristine and team!

  • Regina

    April 30, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    Pristine has been the best partner in helping manage our sandy piece of heaven. Their Owner Reps are a great group — attentive to owner needs and clear in their communication. The whole Pristine team is responsive, and I truly feel they treat the managed properties as if they were their own, taking care of everything from top to bottom. Our objective isn’t 'dollar driven' but 'care driven,' and they do a great job on both.

  • Fran

    April 30, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    Pristine Properties is on their game! They make sure your investment is well cared for and that your rental guests are happy. This is my second property under their care—they’ve been excellent communicators, always friendly, and quick to follow up on any issues. They were the first on site after storm damage, exceeding my expectations. I’ll forever be grateful for their response after Hurricane Michael and for introducing me to the contractors who repaired my previous property and built my new home on Indian Pass.

  • Marie

    April 30, 2025

    5.0out of 5

    Cleanliness
    5.0
    Financial
    5.0
    Maintenance
    5.0
    Responsiveness
    5.0
    Service
    5.0

    Our primary considerations when choosing a rental management company were top-notch cleanliness, maintenance, exceptional guest experience, and profit maximization. Pristine Properties delivers on every front. We appreciate their prompt attention to our inquiries—especially important since we live out of town. We've seen an increase in revenue year after year and value the care they take in managing our home. We are extremely satisfied with Pristine Properties; they truly care about the people they represent and rent to. We strongly recommend them to any owner looking for a rental property management company.

Can I trust Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals?

Comparent verified Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals's identity. It was named 2026 Comparent 100 and The Comparent 100 Page.

Verified by Comparent
Comparent confirmed this company's identity and that the person managing the profile works there.
Granted by Comparent
2026 Comparent 100
Award from Comparent
The Comparent 100 Page
Award from Comparent

Source: verification and awards by Comparent; memberships as declared by Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals. Meanings written by Comparent.

What does Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals do for owners?

Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals says 10 services in all.

  • Trust Accounting
  • Property Inspections
  • Revenue Management/Dynamic Pricing
  • Guest Screening/ID Verification
  • Guest Damage Insurance/Security Deposit Insurance Program
  • Local Support 24/7
  • Tax Compliance and Remittance
  • Commercial Laundry
  • In-house Cleaning
  • Unlimited Owner Use

Source: services the company says it offers. Definitions written by Comparent, the same on every profile.

How big is Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals's business?

Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals manages about 346 properties, as reported by the company, with a team of 26 full-time employees.

Reported by the property manager, not independently verified.

Active properties
322

Property types

Property types
  • Homes79%
  • Condos17%
  • Other4%

Bedroom mix

Bedroom mix
  • 1 bed4%
  • 2 bed22%
  • 3 bed43%
  • 4 bed21%
  • 5 bed6%
  • 6+ bed3%

The metrics and data displayed above are sourced from publicly available information. While Comparent strives to ensure that this information is reliable, please note that the data is not guaranteed for accuracy and should be independently verified. We disclaim any liability for any inaccuracies or omissions in these metrics.

Source: figures reported by Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals; review counts collected by Comparent from Airbnb, Vrbo and Google.

Who will I work with at Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals?

Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals's named contact is Justin Gerlach, CEO.

Justin Gerlach

CEO, Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals

How does Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals report to owners, and who will I work with?

Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals’s answer

Our team is always available to support both homeowners and guests, ensuring seamless communication and prompt assistance every day of the week, including after hours. Homeowners enjoy direct access to a dedicated Owner Relations Manager, offering personalized service and expert guidance. Our online owner portal provides real-time reservation updates, monthly financial statements, and detailed property insights. Guests also benefit from a user-friendly portal with essential stay information and 24/7 support, creating a stress-free experience for everyone. Whether you’re in town for a sit-down review or need quick assistance from afar, we’re here to keep everything running smoothly.

Source: the contact Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals names on Comparent, and its own answer on reporting.

How do I contact Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals?

Send a message with the form below. Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals will see your name, email and message and reply to you directly.

Go to the message form

More questions about Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals

Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals’s own answers, all open.

1. Commission & Costs: Please explain your commission structure and any additional costs a homeowner might incur.

Our commission structure is designed to be both competitive and transparent, tailored to meet the unique needs of each property. We prioritize clarity by discussing any additional costs such as maintenance, housekeeping, or marketing—upfront, ensuring homeowners have a full understanding of their investment.

2. Marketing: Please detail the strategies you utilize to market properties to guests.

We maximize your property's visibility with a strategic, multi-channel marketing approach. Your listing is expertly crafted and showcased across top booking platforms, including Airbnb, Vrbo, and our direct booking website. Targeted email outreach, social media engagement, and digital advertising ensure your home stands out, attracting new guests while encouraging repeat bookings through exclusive incentives.

3. Cleaning & Maintenance: Please outline your property management services, including but not limited to cleaning, inspections and maintenance.

Whether your rental is a short-term getaway or a long-term investment, regular upkeep is key to maximizing revenue. Us, in particular, face unique challenges from the elements, making routine maintenance essential. Our dedicated inspection team—separate from housekeeping—conducts thorough post-departure and periodic vacant-home checks to ensure everything remains in top condition. With a structured inspection process, a guest damage waiver, and an in-house maintenance team, we proactively address issues before they become costly. Annual property evaluations and a comprehensive hurricane protection plan provide added security, so your home stays well-maintained and ready for guests year-round.

5. Financial Management: Please discuss how you handle financial management for the properties you manage. Do you follow trust accounting principles?

At Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals, we prioritize financial transparency and precision in managing your property’s finances. We follow the highest industry standards, including trust accounting practices, to ensure every transaction is handled with care and accuracy.

Your property’s financials are meticulously tracked, with comprehensive reports provided regularly to keep you well-informed. Our team oversees all transactions with security and integrity, giving you peace of mind that your investment is managed with the utmost professionalism.

With our dedicated financial management, you can trust that your returns are maximized while we maintain clear and transparent communication throughout the entire process.

6. Technology: What kind of technology do you employ and how does this technology provide benefits to both homeowners and guests?

At Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals, we utilize state-of-the-art technology to elevate both the owner and guest experience. Our innovative platform provides convenient 24/7 access to personalized online portals, allowing you to stay informed and in control at all times. Guests can easily access important property details, while owners benefit from real-time rental income tracking, ensuring seamless and efficient property management.

7. Differentiators: What unique aspects set your company apart from other property management companies, especially in terms of advantages to homeowners?

At Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals, we’re proud to call the Forgotten Coast our home. We value our people, and they’re passionate about the work they do. With our all-inclusive services, from booking to check-out, you can relax while we handle the details. Our properties are showcased across an extensive range of booking platforms, ensuring maximum exposure. We also offer free professional photography, no-obligation rental projections, and complete transparency with no hidden fees. More visibility leads to higher rates, and with fewer guests, your property experiences less wear and tear.

8. Guest Damage: What is your approach to managing damages caused by guests? Do you require a security deposit or offer damage insurance? If you opt for insurance, how do you establish the coverage details?

At Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals, we've refined our damage waiver policy to provide optimal protection for both owners and guests. The waiver is tiered, with coverage based on property size, ranging from $45 for smaller homes to $75 for larger ones, offering coverage from $1,500 to $3,000. This system is a superior alternative to refundable deposits, as it removes any incentive for guests to conceal damage.

When it comes to damage, we classify it into three areas: Abuse or negligence is the guest's responsibility, and we take proactive measures to protect your investment, even if it means pursuing the guest for damages. Accidental damage is covered by the waiver policy on each booking. Normal wear and tear, however, remains the owner's responsibility.

This approach ensures fair handling of damages and provides peace of mind for everyone involved.

9. Revenue Management: Please explain your strategy for revenue management? How do you determine pricing to optimize earnings? Do you utilize dynamic pricing software, manage rates manually, or employ a combination of both methods?

At Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals, we use advanced dynamic pricing technology to optimize rates, ensuring your property is competitively priced at all times. Our experienced local revenue management team carefully sets rates, adjusting them based on market demand, trends, and occupancy levels.

We take a transparent approach to pricing by offering inclusive rates—meaning the fees are already factored into the displayed price, so guests see the total cost upfront. While the rent itself may be lower, the overall price reflects all associated fees, providing clarity and preventing surprises. This strategy helps drive bookings while maintaining profitability for property owners.

10. Community Involvement and Reputation: Are you involved in the local community and do you support local initiatives?

At our company, we believe in giving back to the community that supports us. We are proud to partner with the local Humane Society, contributing to their mission of providing care and support for animals in need. This commitment reflects our values of compassion and responsibility, and we are dedicated to making a positive impact in our community.

Source: answers written by Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals.

Send a message to Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals.

Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals will see your name, email and message, and will reply to you directly.

Grant Haddock

Grant Haddock

Business Development Executive