Comparent

Magical Stays

Verified — this manager’s identity has been confirmed by Comparent
Headquarters
Davenport, Florida, 33896
Founded in
1999
Full-time employees
6
Markets served
6
  • 4.5Airbnb: 1,409 reviews
  • 4.6Vrbo: 3 reviews

Who is Magical Stays?

Magical Stays is a vacation rental management company based in Davenport, Florida, founded in 1999. It has 6 full-time employees and operates in the Central Florida market. It has a 4.5 rating on Airbnb from 1,409 reviews and a 4.6 rating on Vrbo from 3 reviews.

Source: summary written by Comparent from the facts on this page; description written by the company.

In Magical Stays’s own words

Written by Magical Stays

Who we are and what we are about MAGICAL STAYS reintroduces qualities that’s been missing from the vacation rental industry for years: Integrity and Trust . We believe only in doing the right thing in the right way following the right principles. We believe in delivering guests their dream vacation through trusted experienced service. We believe in doing it, not just talking about it. Doing it, even when no one is watching. Our guests can rely on us to get it right. Everyone on the Magical Stays team is committed to upholding the magical stay promise to our guests. Who we are and what we are about This applies equally to our Home Owners. With over 20 years of professional experience and industry-leading technology, we work hard to earn their trust through our consistent quality service. We love seeing our Owners happy and helping them to earn more, pay less and enjoy their investment. Our “Find Your Happy Place and Stay” motto applies to all of the Magical Stays: our guests, our home owners, our employees and contractors. We are delighted and proud to be called that very “magical happy place” for everyone who chooses Magical Stays to be part of their life. We look forward to bringing the same experience to you! How Magical Stays began It all started long, long ago when a family from England decided to make their dream holiday come true and rented a vacation home near Disney parks. They already knew the hassles and disadvantages of staying in hotels: over-priced limited space and privacy without full size equipped kitchen or private pool to enjoy. They loved their stay in vacation home. It was magical! In fact, they loved it so much, that in 1999 they ended up purchasing their very own vacation home and helped their friends do the same. They started renting and managing these homes and from this grew our company - Loyalty Vacation Homes - becoming one of the first vacation rental companies in Kissimmee. How Magical Stays began From the beginning Loyalty’s goal has not changed: to deliver guests their dream vacation and home owners dream investment through trusted experienced service. That magical feeling everyone gets when creating lifetime memories while vacationing in Orlando is a very powerful thing, and Loyalty has been part of this “magic” from day one and continues to be today! For years Loyalty has added to magical memories through providing guest stays. In the last several years we’ve been going through exciting transformation, bringing the new knowledge and expertise into the company. We felt that we needed to update our brand to better reflect who we are and what we deliver. While Loyalty Vacation Homes has remained our legal name all these years, recently we have adopted our new name - Magical Stays. This change has been designed to satisfy all the existing expectations of what our original company always stood for, while simultaneously moving the focus to both the spirit and location of our homes, making Magical Stays name speak loud to the experience that awaits everyone we come in contact with. We look forward to bringing this magical place for you to stay soon!

Where does Magical Stays manage vacation rentals?

Magical Stays serves one market on Comparent: Central Florida, FL. Its headquarters is in Davenport, FL.

Source: places and property counts reported by the company.

How do homeowners rate Magical Stays?

4.5 on Airbnb (1409); 4.6 on Vrbo (3).

  • 4.5Airbnb: 1,409 reviews
  • 4.6Vrbo: 3 reviews

Source: homeowner reviews collected on Comparent; other ratings collected by Comparent from those sites. As of: Airbnb and Vrbo ratings collected Nov 2026.

No homeowner has reviewed Magical Stays on Comparent yet.

Write the first review

Can I trust Magical Stays?

Comparent verified Magical Stays's identity. It lists 1 membership, including Vrbo Premier Partner.

Verified by Comparent
Comparent confirmed this company's identity and that the person managing the profile works there.
Granted by Comparent
Vrbo Premier Partner
Declared by the company

Source: verification and awards by Comparent; memberships as declared by Magical Stays. Meanings written by Comparent.

What does Magical Stays do for owners?

Magical Stays says 12 services in all.

  • Trust Accounting
  • Property Inspections
  • Revenue Management/Dynamic Pricing
  • Local Ownership
  • Guest Screening/ID Verification
  • Guest Damage Insurance/Security Deposit Insurance Program
  • Local Support 24/7
  • Tax Compliance and Remittance
  • In-house Cleaning
  • Keyless Entry Provided
  • No Startup Fees
  • Unlimited Owner Use

Source: services the company says it offers. Definitions written by Comparent, the same on every profile.

How big is Magical Stays's business?

Magical Stays's size, as reported by the company, with a team of 6 full-time employees.

Reported by the property manager, not independently verified.

Average annual occupancy
80%
Active properties
101
Average daily rate
$181
Occupancy
37%
Reviews per property
21.5

Property types

Property types
  • Homes78%
  • Condos8%
  • Other14%

Bedroom mix

Bedroom mix
  • 2 bed7%
  • 3 bed33%
  • 4 bed37%
  • 5 bed11%
  • 6+ bed13%
Active properties
9
Average daily rate
$537
Occupancy
14%
Reviews per property
1.0

Property types

Property types
  • Homes100%

Bedroom mix

Bedroom mix
  • 3 bed44%
  • 4 bed22%
  • 5 bed11%
  • 6+ bed22%

The metrics and data displayed above are sourced from publicly available information. While Comparent strives to ensure that this information is reliable, please note that the data is not guaranteed for accuracy and should be independently verified. We disclaim any liability for any inaccuracies or omissions in these metrics.

Source: figures reported by Magical Stays; review counts collected by Comparent from Airbnb, Vrbo and Google.

Questions Magical Stays hasn't answered yet

Magical Stays hasn’t claimed this listing yet, so it hasn’t given Comparent these answers. You can ask in your message, or compare other managers who have.

Who will I work with at Magical Stays?
No named contact listed.

How do I contact Magical Stays?

Send a message with the form below. Magical Stays will see your name, email and message and reply to you directly.

Go to the message form